Hanukkah is a holiday celebrated from within darkness. During the darkest moments of the year, when the sun is hidden from view and the world outside is dominated by cold, we celebrate a festival of light, a holiday when we are instructed to light a candle and illuminate the world.
One of the interesting laws related to lighting the Hanukkah candles focuses on where this should happen, ideally at the entrance of the home facing the street. Unlike many other mitzvot, in which the focus is on the individual, here there is a very public aspect; others must see the hanukkiah – the Hanukkah menorah – and enjoy its light.
However, this custom is complicated by what the Talmud describes as “times of danger.” In such moments, when it is too dangerous or impossible to illuminate the outside, we are instructed to turn the light inward: “In times of danger, one places it on the table, and that suffices” (Babylonian Talmud, Shabbat, 21b).
This Talmudic verse reminds us that the world has not always been kind to the Jewish People. It wasn’t always possible to celebrate Hanukkah everywhere without fear. This raises the question: How does one celebrate Hanukkah in times of danger? The Talmud’s answer is intriguing. On the one hand, we do not give up on the tradition of lighting the candles and spreading light. On the other hand, the focus shifts. Instead of illuminating the world outside, the hanukkiah should be lit inside the home, placed atop a table. This stems from the fact that danger lurks outside – the external dangers that have led to the persecution of Jews for centuries. Inside the home, however, the hanukkiah can be lit, and its light can provide comfort.
Throughout history, there have been many accounts of Hanukkah celebrations and candle-lightings performed during such dangerous times – in some cases even specifically because of the danger. Lighting these candles, which are linked to the victory of the Maccabees, becomes an act of hope and significance during times of danger, reminding us of a different era of Jewish sovereignty, when the Jewish People managed to triumph over their enemies and uphold their traditions, a memory that gives us the strength to withstand our current darkness.
In the Cairo Genizah, letters in Judeo-Arabic were found referencing family Hanukkah celebrations and expressing prayers for salvation akin to the salvation the Jews experienced in the Hanukkah story. Translated into English, one such letter reads: “During these noble, famous days referenced in [the song] Ha’Nissim (the miracles), may He who performed miracles for our ancestors in those days in this time also perform with Your Holy Eminence for the rest of the wretched flock.”
This is a request for salvation that is closely linked to the miracle of Hanukkah, hoping that at this time, as the people are once again experiencing a time of danger, they may be sent a Hanukkah miracle as well.
Yemenite Jewish tradition recalls that it was on the fifth night of Hanukkah that a decree of expulsion for the Jews of Sana’a was canceled and they were spared exile and allowed to return to their homes. As a result, the fifth night became a special celebration for the Jews of Yemen, when they marked this double miracle of salvation.
A less optimistic tale recounts the story of Rabbi Meir in the Warsaw Ghetto who was determined to light Hanukkah candles. He went to great lengths before the holiday to procure oil amid the dire scarcity. When Hanukkah arrived, he lit the oil wicks by the window, as was his custom. Tragically, this act led to his public and brutal execution by the Nazis.
There are many testimonies about how Hanukkah was marked during World War II, and the efforts made by Jews during the Holocaust to light candles despite the struggle for survival, primarily to remember who they were and what they stood for. Those who survived this lighting often did so by following the Talmudic teaching of lighting the Hanukkiah inside, away from the hostile gaze of their persecutors.
As a 14-year-old in the Andrychow Ghetto, Ruth Lieblich wrote in her diary in 1941: “No, there were no candles on Hanukkah, but in our hearts burned a fire of love and hope that this will never happen again, that the Jewish people will never again be so poor that they cannot light candles.” She described how they only managed to light candles on the first night of Hanukkah because there simply weren’t enough available and the act itself was too dangerous. But the fire burned in their hearts, strengthening them and sending them the courage to dream of days when Jews would be able to light candles without fear.
In 1965, Joseph Schneider, a refusenik and Prisoner of Zion, used his camera to document a special occasion when candles were lit during a clandestine Hanukkah party in the Soviet Union. These rare photographs were taken at a time and place where it was prohibited for Jews to celebrate and hold religious ceremonies. The photos show that the hanukkiah was lit in accordance with the Talmud’s instruction for times of danger – on a table, inside the home, illuminating everything inside and providing light to a family that had chosen to mark its Judaism while concealing it from those outside.
Last year, many of us found ourselves asking similar questions. Some of us are still asking those questions today.
Indeed, the situation for many of us is far better than that of Jews in the past who had no candles to light or were persecuted because of their Judaism. However, it is still difficult to celebrate when so many people are still displaced from their homes, when there are hostages still being held in Gaza, and when so many parents are serving as reservists with the Israel Defense Forces and protecting our borders.
Last year on Hanukkah, as a reservist’s wife, I was drained. I stood in front of the hanukkiah with my kids, completely worn out, and wondered how we could even celebrate. Right then, amid our time of danger, I received a photo from one of the officers in my husband’s battalion. It showed the soldiers lighting Hanukkah candles inside Gaza. They didn’t have a regular hanukkiah but instead had improvised one out of tin, yet the light shone brightly.
When my husband returned from Gaza, I asked why it had been so important for them to light a hanukkiah in between missions. After all, they had such little time to rest at night when they weren’t fighting. He explained that the very act of lighting Hanukkah candles had given them strength. He said it helped them – religious and secular alike – think about how our people had overcome challenges in the past. Lighting the hanukkiah gave them hope that there was indeed still light in the world and that we would all get through this crisis. It reminded them that their own actions could help bring back the light.
This year, too, he will once again be on reserve duty while we will be home without him. This year, too, so many families will find it hard to celebrate due to the impact of the war. But this year, I can better understand the words of the Talmud. In times of danger, we need to focus inward. In times of danger, the purpose of the hanukkiah is to illuminate our souls, kindle our hope, and help us believe that we can bring back the light.